November 07, 2003
David Frum Takedown

Extraordinary (and long) hammering of David Frum's Dead Right.

The funny thing about this book is: it isn’t nearly as bad I just made it sound. I don’t think Frum is obsessed with beards or anything, actually. He sometimes seems like a pretty sharp guy. The middle chapters – full of history and policy detail, so forth – are quite cogent. Just the main chapters have problems. Frum has written a book about the need for a reflective, conservative philosophy. And: that’s the one thing he hasn’t got. He just has no clue why he is a conservative, or why being one might be a good idea – or even what ‘conservatism’ ought to mean. Whenever he starts trying to talk about that stuff, his mind just goes blank and he fantasizes about shaving beards and the Donner party.

Posted by Bill Stilwell at November 07, 2003 11:26 AM
Comments
Post a comment:
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?